I just don't understand Will some days. Will is almost 11 and I don't know if what he is going through is your typical preteen angst or what, but some days I could shake him. I don't, but I want to. Here's just an example of what we're dealing with:
Will to me: Daniel just punched me.
Me: Why did he do that?
Will: *shrugs* I dunno.
Me: So you're telling me Daniel got up from his chair and walked over to you and punched you for no reason? Just out of the blue? [I'm not doubting that Daniel punched him at this point and did plan to talk with Daniel about hitting, I just knew that Daniel had been provoked in some way.]
Will: Well, no. I was telling him to stop and he got mad and hit me.
Me: Will, I'm not buying it. You didn't do anything to him?
Will: No.
Me: Go get him and Clayton come back to me.
*waits for them to come back*
Me to Daniel: Daniel did you hit Will?
Daniel: Yeah, but it was because he was doing this. *puts his fist in my face, an inch from my nose*
Me to Clayton: Is that what happened Clayton?
Clayton: Yes
Me to Daniel: Daniel, we don't hit our brothers. If he's doing something mean to you, you need to tell me or dad.
*looks at Will*
Will: I was just messing with him.
Me: I asked you what you did to provoke Daniel to hit you and you said all you did was tell him to stop, you didn't tell me anything about messing with him or putting your fist in his face. You lied.
Will: *stares at me blankly*
Neely to Will: Will, you can go to bed after dinner for lying, how about that?
Will to Neely: fine
Now, honestly. Had he just told me that he was messing with Daniel, I would probably have told him to leave Daniel alone and got onto Daniel about hitting. But now he's spending his night, starting at 6:30, in his room, alone, without tv or any games. I just really don't get it. I've raised a boy before, so I'm not new to this. But usually when confronted James was honest about things. Hey may not have been remorseful all the time, but he would usually cop to what he did. Will, on the other hand, would rather lie than tell the truth. I can't tell if it's a pathological thing where he doesn't think about what he's saying before he says it, or if it's premeditated, in a way to keep himself from getting in trouble.
We have told him, repeatedly, that it's the lying that we hate most of all, and usually it's the lying that gets him in hot water, but it's just not getting through. He's not a bad kid. He has been really good in school this year, after his initial adjustment to the new school and new living situation. Pretty much the only problem we have with him, is the lying. I mean, he is a typical boy. He does fight with his brothers and does get in trouble for other things, but not nearly as often as lying.
We just don't know what to do at this point. We're willing to try anything. But right now, banging my head against the wall is what I'll settle for.